A look back at Express Entry's historic year, as well as a look ahead. The last time candidates for the Federal Skilled Worker Program (FSWP) were picked from the Express Entry pool was on December 23, 2020. Most of us had no idea at the time that it would signal the start of a temporary halt in Express Entry invitations to FSWP candidates.
Since its inception in 1967, the FSWP has been Canada's principal avenue for low-income immigrants and a major boost for Canada immigration policies. The Canadian Experience Class was introduced by Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) in 2008 to supplement the FSWP (CEC). The CEC aims to create a specific immigration path for Canadian job experience (international students and temporary foreign workers). The Immigration and Refugee Commission (IRCC) established the Federal Skilled Trades Program (FSTP) in 2013 to provide an immigration pathway for skilled trades professionals.
IRCC created Express Entry in 2015 to oversee these three programs. Anyone who met the requirements of an Express Entry-managed program could create a profile and receive a Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) score based on human capital criteria such as age, education, English and/or French language skills, work experience, and Canadian experience, among other things. IRCC will invite the highest-scoring individuals to apply for Canada PR every two weeks.
The rationale for Express Entry was that it would allow IRCC to process applications more quickly (because they only needed to process those who were invited, as opposed to the previous model of reviewing every single application) and would give new immigrants a better chance of integrating into the Canadian economy (since IRCC was skimming the top to invite the highest-scoring candidates).
FSWP applicants received the most Express Entry invites between 2015 and the start of the epidemic. They got around 45 percent of all invites in 2019, followed by CEC candidates. All of this came to an end in 2021. IRCC started 2021 with a strategy for achieving its Immigration Levels Plan goal of landing 401,000 new permanent residents by the end of the year. The proposal called for a higher number of temporary residents staying in Canada during the epidemic to be granted permanent residency.
Get a Free Express Entry Assessment
The plan's rationale was that in the face of COVID disruptions such as travel restrictions and other obstacles that may prevent overseas candidates from completing the permanent residence process, focusing on transitioning those already in Canada was the best bet for meeting the 401,000-newcomer target in 2021.
For much of this year, the strategy comprised shifting from evaluating all applicants in Express Entry to predominantly accepting CEC candidates, including the unprecedented February 13 draw that invited all 27,332 CEC candidates in the pool at the time (almost six-times more than the previous record for invitations in one draw). The proposal also called for implementing a one-time special public policy that would allow up to 90,000 vital employees and international graduates in Canada to seek permanent residency.
One has the right to argue the decision's merits to exclude FSWP applicants from Express Entry lotteries for the next year and a half. In reality, we will have plenty of time to argue the decision's merits as a variety of developments, such as the worldwide pandemic situation, IRCC's future policy decisions, and operational capacity, Canada's labour market picture, and the economic integration of Express Entry immigrants, continue to unfold. However, all of this implies that we will most likely need years to thoroughly examine the consequences of this decision. Nonetheless, based on our knowledge today, it is worthwhile to weigh the benefits and downsides of the option.
Advantages of excluding FSWP candidates
IRCC is on track to meet its newcomer target for the year, as it already receives over 45,000 new permanent residents per month and has received over 360,000 immigrants during the first eleven months of 2021. As a result, IRCC would claim that despite the tough choice to disqualify FSWP candidates, it could get a greater level of permanent residence in a challenging working environment.
Another advantage is that, according to Statistics Canada, persons with Canadian job experience tend to integrate successfully into the labour market once granted permanent residency. In addition to domestic work experience, individuals may enhance their language skills and network while in Canada as temporary residents, which improves their post-arrival job opportunities.
Third, Canada has had labour shortages throughout the epidemic. IRCC's concentration on Canadian applicants has allowed the country to take a more focused strategy to alleviate poverty and needs, particularly in critical occupations. For example, many of the essential workers who applied under IRCC's temporary public policy would not have had an opportunity to earn permanent residency if IRCC had not decided to reject FSWP applicants this year.
Disadvantages of excluding FSWP candidates
On the other side, one may argue that IRCC could meet its 401,000-newcomer objective while also inviting FSWP applicants. The reason for this is that there is typically a one-year or more gap between when an FSWP candidate is accepted and when they physically arrive in Canada. As a result, IRCC could have started issuing Express Entry invites to FSWP candidates in the second half of the year while still landing as many in-Canada applications as possible to meet its 2021 levels plan objective.
In fact, an internal IRCC letter discloses that the department considered this idea, although it is unknown why they did not pursue it. Another disadvantage of the decision is that it has reduced openness and confidence between FSWP applicants and the IRCC. The Canadian government and IRCC take themselves in being as open and transparent as possible. Still, they have not communicated anything to FSWP candidates regarding IRCC's Express Entry intentions for 2021 and beyond.
This is significant since many FSWP hopefuls approached the Express Entry pool in earnest this year, hoping for a chance to be chosen, but were turned down. Essentially, IRCC invites them to the restaurant but refuses to provide them with food.
Perhaps a better strategy would have been for IRCC to clearly express its objectives, allowing FSWP applicants to consider alternate options. In addition, since language test results are only valid for two years and Educational Credential Assessments (ECA) are valid for five years, the choice to omit them may negatively impact some candidates.
In the grand scheme of things, retaking a language test or applying for another ECA isn't the end of the world. Still, it would have been more considerate of IRCC to provide FSWP candidates with advance notice so they could avoid potential inconveniences in their pursuit of Canadian permanent residence.
Another disadvantage is that IRCC undermines the policy reason for Express Entry in the first place. For example, when Express Entry was first introduced in 2015, IRCC was ecstatic about the evidence-based methodology underpinning the Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS).
The CRS, according to IRCC, was developed by several years of longitudinal data on the labour market performance of immigrants gathered and analyzed by Statistics Canada. As a result, the CRS score was created to reward candidates who are younger in age, have more education, work experience, language abilities, Canadian experience, and may have additional advantages such as a Canadian job offer or siblings residing in Canada.
However, with the decision to exclude FSWP applicants, IRCC has only been inviting individuals qualified for the CEC as well as the Provincial Nominee Program (some PNP streams are aligned with Express Entry). As a result, CRS score criteria have been reduced, allowing IRCC to meet its 401,000-newcomer objective.
This agile approach is admirable, but it may come at a cost. That is, applicants with lower CRS scores who received permanent residency invites in 2021 may have poorer labour market results than candidates who would have received invitations under more typical conditions (that is, being invited on the basis of having one of the highest CRS scores rather than based on meeting CEC eligibility criteria).
IRCC has constantly claimed that Express Entry is intended to be long-term. Therefore, according to IRCC, inviting applicants with the highest CRS scores is a wise approach since their strong human capital will allow them to adjust to the dynamic nature of the Canadian labour market. While this is an extreme scenario, it exemplifies the decision made by IRCC: the department determined that inviting a CEC applicant with a CRS score of 75 (as in the February 13 draw) was more necessary than inviting an FSWP candidate with a CRS score of 470 to meet its 2021 levels objective (the rough cut-off requirement before this year).
Another disadvantage identified by IRCC is that the choice to focus on candidates in Canada has worsened backlogs since IRCC has been processing permanent residence applications from people living abroad at a slower rate.
Given IRCC's lack of information about its Express Entry objectives, no one can estimate when it will restart invites to FSWP candidates. There are, however, a few points to bear in mind.
To begin, IRCC has been eliminating CEC applicants from drawings since September to clear its backlog. The agency has stated that it intends to reduce Express Entry backlogs by half before welcoming FSWP, CEC, and Federal Skilled Trades Program candidates again. Based on its present application processing rate, IRCC might be in this position by the first part of 2022.
Given the importance of FSWP applicants as a source of talent, IRCC will eventually need to restart invitations to them. As previously stated, they made up 45 percent of all invited candidates in 2019 and have recently made-up 85 percent of all candidates in the Express Entry pool. IRCC may soon run out of CEC candidates to invite and may have already reached that stage.
Another important factor to consider is that IRCC is critical to Canada's economic success. The agency encourages the entrance of permanent residents from other countries, therefore contributing to Canada's population, labour force, and economic growth.
However, the epidemic has hampered international immigration, contributing to Canada's slowest population increase in more than a century. Furthermore, the country is seeing some of the largest levels of job vacancies on record for various reasons, including a shortage of fresh employees from overseas. As a result, resuming FSWP draws will be critical to achieving Canada's economic growth goals.
Finally, while it made sense to remove FSWP applicants from drawings when Canada imposed harsher travel limits, it makes less sense now that Canada has eased travel restrictions on all Confirmation of Permanent Residence (COPR) holders. Although the number of COVID cases worldwide is increasing, there are presently no Canadian government travel restrictions restricting FSWP candidates with COPRs from visiting Canada.
And, as previously stated, it takes approximately one year from the time an FSWP receives an invitation to the time they arrive in Canada, so pandemic volatility should not be the primary reason for continuing to hold off on FSWP invitations because none of us know what the world has in store for us one year or so from now. All of this to say, there looks to be a good argument for IRCC to begin FSWP invites in 2022.
Tags: coronavirus, covid, CRS, CRS score, express entry, fstp, fswp, immigration levels plan, IRCC, jobs, labour market, PNP, settlement, Canada immmigrtion news
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 02 Feb, 2021 | 03:26 AM] 652
By Eva Olsen [Published 11 Feb, 2021 | 07:00 AM] 2232
By Eva Olsen [Published 12 Feb, 2021 | 04:00 AM] 999
By Joseph Parker [Published 18 Feb, 2021 | 06:00 AM] 602
By Eva Olsen [Published 19 Feb, 2021 | 07:00 AM] 633
By Eva Olsen [Published 24 Feb, 2021 | 05:00 AM] 879
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 09 Mar, 2021 | 04:14 AM] 838
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 18 Mar, 2021 | 06:55 AM] 992
By Eva Olsen [Published 01 Apr, 2021 | 04:24 AM] 854
By Joseph Parker [Published 13 Apr, 2021 | 04:55 AM] 628
By Eva Olsen [Published 14 Apr, 2021 | 04:58 AM] 728
By Joseph Parker [Published 15 Apr, 2021 | 05:10 AM] 1261
By Eva Olsen [Published 19 Apr, 2021 | 04:10 AM] 723
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 21 Apr, 2021 | 05:25 AM] 874
By Eva Olsen [Published 21 Apr, 2021 | 05:25 AM] 1320
By Joseph Parker [Published 20 Apr, 2021 | 04:54 AM] 1022
By Eva Olsen [Published 23 Apr, 2021 | 04:21 AM] 687
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 03 May, 2021 | 04:53 AM] 912
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 05 May, 2021 | 05:04 AM] 963
By Eva Olsen [Published 05 May, 2021 | 05:30 AM] 975
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 May, 2021 | 04:34 AM] 1214
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 14 May, 2021 | 04:14 AM] 645
By Eva Olsen [Published 14 May, 2021 | 04:34 AM] 846
By Joseph Parker [Published 21 May, 2021 | 04:50 AM] 1013
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 22 May, 2021 | 04:02 AM] 921
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 27 May, 2021 | 04:36 AM] 1002
By Eva Olsen [Published 03 Jun, 2021 | 04:42 AM] 954
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 08 Jun, 2021 | 05:29 AM] 716
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 09 Jun, 2021 | 05:41 AM] 642
By Joseph Parker [Published 10 Jun, 2021 | 05:39 AM] 651
By Eva Olsen [Published 11 Jun, 2021 | 03:55 AM] 1057
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 19 Jun, 2021 | 04:54 AM] 831
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 22 Jun, 2021 | 04:08 AM] 619
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 26 Jun, 2021 | 05:40 AM] 637
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 06 Jul, 2021 | 04:41 AM] 911
By Eva Olsen [Published 19 Jul, 2021 | 05:28 AM] 611
By Joseph Parker [Published 20 Jul, 2021 | 04:16 AM] 852
By Eva Olsen [Published 21 Jul, 2021 | 04:37 AM] 818
By Joseph Parker [Published 28 Jul, 2021 | 04:39 AM] 714
By Joseph Parker [Published 02 Aug, 2021 | 04:29 AM] 1139
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 11 Aug, 2021 | 05:23 AM] 629
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 16 Aug, 2021 | 05:13 AM] 1243
By Joseph Parker [Published 17 Aug, 2021 | 05:45 AM] 1011
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 23 Aug, 2021 | 04:26 AM] 978
By Eva Olsen [Published 08 Sep, 2021 | 04:25 AM] 947
By Eva Olsen [Published 10 Sep, 2021 | 04:23 AM] 712
By Joseph Parker [Published 14 Sep, 2021 | 05:40 AM] 834
By Joseph Parker [Published 21 Sep, 2021 | 05:35 AM] 905
By Eva Olsen [Published 23 Sep, 2021 | 04:28 AM] 704
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 24 Sep, 2021 | 04:40 AM] 911
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 02 Oct, 2021 | 04:24 PM] 1087
By Eva Olsen [Published 05 Oct, 2021 | 04:32 AM] 1156
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 Oct, 2021 | 04:48 AM] 1155
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 06 Oct, 2021 | 05:45 AM] 1209
By Joseph Parker [Published 12 Oct, 2021 | 04:26 AM] 963
By Eva Olsen [Published 14 Oct, 2021 | 05:45 AM] 1014
By Joseph Parker [Published 18 Oct, 2021 | 04:45 AM] 703
By Joseph Parker [Published 19 Oct, 2021 | 05:55 AM] 894
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 20 Oct, 2021 | 04:45 AM] 1646
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 21 Oct, 2021 | 04:47 AM] 853
By Eva Olsen [Published 21 Oct, 2021 | 05:03 AM] 3406
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 01 Nov, 2021 | 04:41 AM] 16627
By Joseph Parker [Published 10 Nov, 2021 | 05:42 AM] 782
By Eva Olsen [Published 23 Nov, 2021 | 05:08 AM] 694
By Joseph Parker [Published 26 Nov, 2021 | 04:35 AM] 1662
By Joseph Parker [Published 30 Nov, 2021 | 04:55 AM] 987
By Eva Olsen [Published 01 Dec, 2021 | 05:02 AM] 845
By Joseph Parker [Published 02 Dec, 2021 | 04:55 AM] 1203
By Eva Olsen [Published 03 Dec, 2021 | 05:17 AM] 1434
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 Dec, 2021 | 05:22 AM] 900
By Eva Olsen [Published 13 Dec, 2021 | 04:32 AM] 1104
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 15 Dec, 2021 | 04:38 AM] 5736
By Eva Olsen [Published 15 Dec, 2021 | 05:47 AM] 793
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 16 Dec, 2021 | 05:42 AM] 983
By Eva Olsen [Published 17 Dec, 2021 | 04:32 AM] 827
By Joseph Parker [Published 22 Dec, 2021 | 05:11 AM] 1031
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 27 Dec, 2021 | 04:52 AM] 812
By Eva Olsen [Published 27 Dec, 2021 | 05:38 AM] 844
By Eva Olsen [Published 29 Dec, 2021 | 05:43 AM] 3534
By Joseph Parker [Published 29 Dec, 2021 | 04:28 AM] 754
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 30 Dec, 2021 | 03:58 AM] 1255
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 03 Jan, 2022 | 05:26 AM] 755
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 05 Jan, 2022 | 03:05 AM] 1585
By Eva Olsen [Published 05 Jan, 2022 | 06:22 AM] 965
By Eva Olsen [Published 07 Jan, 2022 | 04:53 AM] 1230
By Joseph Parker [Published 07 Jan, 2022 | 05:36 AM] 5138
By Joseph Parker [Published 10 Jan, 2022 | 05:32 AM] 1112
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 17 Jan, 2022 | 05:11 AM] 1240
By Eva Olsen [Published 19 Jan, 2022 | 04:03 AM] 2427
By Eva Olsen [Published 24 Jan, 2022 | 04:43 AM] 1112
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 25 Jan, 2022 | 05:17 AM] 1283
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 26 Jan, 2022 | 05:21 AM] 2071
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 27 Jan, 2022 | 05:07 AM] 2178
By Eva Olsen [Published 31 Jan, 2022 | 04:41 AM] 1347
By Joseph Parker [Published 01 Feb, 2022 | 04:32 AM] 1618
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 02 Feb, 2022 | 04:42 AM] 1410
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 04 Feb, 2022 | 05:15 AM] 1370
By Eva Olsen [Published 05 Feb, 2022 | 04:23 AM] 8526
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 07 Feb, 2022 | 04:51 AM] 947
By Eva Olsen [Published 07 Feb, 2022 | 05:11 AM] 963
By Joseph Parker [Published 08 Feb, 2022 | 05:46 AM] 1142
By Eva Olsen [Published 11 Feb, 2022 | 05:24 AM] 1361
By Joseph Parker [Published 14 Feb, 2022 | 04:55 AM] 1176
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 16 Feb, 2022 | 04:50 AM] 1221
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 17 Feb, 2022 | 05:12 AM] 2054
By Joseph Parker [Published 19 Feb, 2022 | 05:33 AM] 1551
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 25 Feb, 2022 | 05:39 AM] 1402
By Joseph Parker [Published 01 Mar, 2022 | 04:53 AM] 1194
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 02 Mar, 2022 | 04:23 AM] 1503
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 04 Mar, 2022 | 05:03 AM] 1336
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 05 Mar, 2022 | 05:41 AM] 1463
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 11 Mar, 2022 | 05:45 AM] 1414
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 14 Mar, 2022 | 04:17 AM] 1460
By Joseph Parker [Published 15 Mar, 2022 | 04:14 AM] 2504
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 16 Mar, 2022 | 04:10 AM] 1588
By Eva Olsen [Published 22 Mar, 2022 | 10:25 AM] 1159
By Eva Olsen [Published 22 Mar, 2022 | 06:32 AM] 1136
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 28 Mar, 2022 | 05:21 AM] 999
By Eva Olsen [Published 04 Apr, 2022 | 05:10 AM] 1699
By Eva Olsen [Published 05 Apr, 2022 | 05:44 AM] 2429
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 Apr, 2022 | 05:57 AM] 1401
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 07 Apr, 2022 | 05:07 AM] 1235
By Eva Olsen [Published 08 Apr, 2022 | 05:33 AM] 1029
By Eva Olsen [Published 13 Apr, 2022 | 03:34 PM] 16985
By Joseph Parker [Published 18 Apr, 2022 | 05:28 AM] 786
By Eva Olsen [Published 21 Apr, 2022 | 05:43 AM] 977
By Eva Olsen [Published 23 Apr, 2022 | 11:53 AM] 1755
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 30 Apr, 2022 | 05:12 AM] 684
By Joseph Parker [Published 02 May, 2022 | 05:10 AM] 1130
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 May, 2022 | 05:32 AM] 1222
By Joseph Parker [Published 20 May, 2022 | 05:00 AM] 1040
By Eva Olsen [Published 30 May, 2022 | 05:36 AM] 909
By Joseph Parker [Published 31 May, 2022 | 05:04 AM] 962
By Eva Olsen [Published 02 Jun, 2022 | 05:00 AM] 1225
By Eva Olsen [Published 08 Jun, 2022 | 05:20 AM] 871
By Eva Olsen [Published 14 Jun, 2022 | 04:51 AM] 780
By Joseph Parker [Published 21 Jun, 2022 | 06:11 AM] 1376
By Joseph Parker [Published 27 Jun, 2022 | 10:02 AM] 1225
By Eva Olsen [Published 14 Jul, 2022 | 03:02 PM] 824
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 19 Jul, 2022 | 04:44 AM] 897
By Joseph Parker [Published 02 Aug, 2022 | 10:12 AM] 745
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 10 Aug, 2022 | 08:10 AM] 810
By Eva Olsen [Published 27 Sep, 2022 | 07:18 AM] 908
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 28 Sep, 2022 | 05:34 AM] 473
By Eva Olsen [Published 03 Oct, 2022 | 07:12 AM] 736
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 07 Oct, 2022 | 08:05 AM] 860
By Eva Olsen [Published 13 Oct, 2022 | 11:38 AM] 1042
By Joseph Parker [Published 19 Oct, 2022 | 08:10 AM] 813
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 02 Nov, 2022 | 06:35 AM] 1812
By Joseph Parker [Published 16 Nov, 2022 | 08:20 AM] 1523
By Joseph Parker [Published 28 Nov, 2022 | 03:55 AM] 543
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 03 Dec, 2022 | 06:15 AM] 570
By Joseph Parker [Published 06 Dec, 2022 | 08:36 AM] 414
By Joseph Parker [Published 29 Dec, 2022 | 04:26 PM] 590
By Joseph Parker [Published 04 Jan, 2023 | 06:20 AM] 595
By Eva Olsen [Published 10 Jan, 2023 | 06:28 AM] 613
By Eva Olsen [Published 20 Jan, 2023 | 06:48 AM] 16045
By Joseph Parker [Published 25 Jan, 2023 | 04:21 AM] 873
By Eva Olsen [Published 04 Feb, 2023 | 07:57 AM] 9853
By Joseph Parker [Published 07 Feb, 2023 | 06:24 AM] 3152
By Joseph Parker [Published 11 Feb, 2023 | 06:27 AM] 1958
By Joseph Parker [Published 17 Feb, 2023 | 07:45 AM] 737
By Scarlett Wilson [Published 20 Feb, 2023 | 06:42 AM] 605
Stay up to date with the latest news
Comments
We welcome your feedback
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *